flooring comparison guide

resources | Flooring comparison guide

overview

This comprehensive guide is designed to cut through the jargon and help you confidently select the perfect flooring to match your style, lifestyle, and budget. We'll walk you through all the popular options, from classic hardwood to modern luxury vinyl, and arm you with the knowledge you need to make a smart choice and enjoy your floors for years to come!

contents

Find Your Perfect Flooring

Question 1 of 5

Higher budgets allow for premium and durable materials.

If you have pets, children, or high foot traffic, a highly durable floor is recommended. Lower durability options work well in low-traffic areas.

Bathrooms, kitchens, and basements often require water-resistant flooring while less moisture-prone areas can accommodate standard wood flooring.

If you love the aesthetics of real wood, there are many great choices. If looks are less important, we may recommend other practical options.

Some floors offer click-lock installation for DIYers, while others like solid hardwood require professional installation.

flooring comparison overview

Flooring Type Durability Water Resistance Material Cost Maintenance Best For...
Engineered Hardwood Good to Excellent Fair to Good Mid-Range Easy Living Rooms, Bedrooms, Hallways
Prefinished Solid Hardwood Excellent Poor Higher Moderate Living Rooms, Dining Rooms, Formal Areas
Laminate Good Fair to Good Budget-Friendly Easy Living Rooms, Bedrooms, Playrooms
Luxury Vinyl Plank (LVP) Excellent Excellent Mid-Range Very Easy Kitchens, Bathrooms, Basements, High Traffic Areas
Luxury Vinyl Tile (LVT) Excellent Excellent Mid-Range Very Easy Kitchens, Bathrooms, Entryways
Sheet Vinyl Good Excellent Budget-Friendly Very Easy Bathrooms, Laundry Rooms, Budget Projects

frequently asked questions

What's the difference between Luxury Vinyl Plank (LVP) and Luxury Vinyl Tile (LVT)?

Appearance: LVP is designed to look like hardwood planks. LVT is designed to look like tile or stone.

Shape: LVP comes in plank shapes (long and narrow). LVT comes in tile shapes (square or rectangular).

Functionally: They are very similar in terms of durability, water resistance, and installation. The main difference is aesthetics – choose based on whether you prefer a wood-look or tile-look floor. (Quick tip: "Think about the room. Wood-look LVP is popular for living areas and bedrooms, tile-look LVT for kitchens and baths)

What's the difference between Luxury Vinyl Plank (LVP) and Laminate?

Water Resistance: LVP is WATERPROOF (or highly water-resistant). Laminate is NOT water-resistant (unless specifically labeled "waterproof laminate," which is still generally less reliably waterproof than LVP). This is the biggest practical difference.

Material Composition: LVP is made of vinyl (plastic). Laminate is made of composite wood product with a photographic layer and wear layer.

Durability: LVP is generally more dent and scratch resistant, especially high-quality LVP with thicker wear layers. Both are durable, but LVP often wins in high-traffic, pet-friendly homes.

Feel Underfoot: LVP can feel slightly softer and warmer underfoot, especially WPC core LVP. Laminate can feel harder and sometimes colder.

Price: Laminate is generally less expensive upfront. LVP can be a bit more of an investment initially, but its superior water resistance and durability can offer better long-term value, especially in moisture-prone areas.

engineered hardwood

Light and clean hardwood flooring in a furnished home. Full size for desktop

What is Engineered Hardwood?

Real wood veneer layered over a stable core. More moisture-resistant than solid wood. Various veneer thicknesses and wood species available. Good for climates with humidity changes and families.

best for:

Living rooms, bedrooms, hallways, basements (better than solid wood). Homes with kids/pets benefit from thicker veneers.

Key benefits:

  • More stable and water resistant than solid hardwood

  • Get a real wood look and feel

main Drawbacks:

  • Veneer can still scratch

  • Limited refinishing depending on thickness

  • Not completely water resistant

material cost:

$3 - $12+ per sq ft

installation cost:

get a free quote

prefinished solid hardwood

Cherry Solid Wood flooring installed in a new home. Full size for desktop

What is pre-finished solid hardwood?

Classic, timeless flooring made from solid planks of wood, pre-sanded and finished. The traditional "gold standard."

best for:

Living rooms, dining rooms, formal areas in stable humidity climates. Homeowners prioritizing classic look and resale value.

Key benefits:

  • Timeless beauty

  • Lasting value

  • Refinishable for decades

main Drawbacks:

  • Poor water resistance

  • Susceptible to humidity

  • Higher cost

  • Professional install recommended

material cost:

$6 - $20+ per sq ft

installation cost:

get a free quote

laminate flooring

Light grey laminate flooring installed in an apartment. Full sized for desktop

What is laminate flooring?

Synthetic, multi-layer flooring mimicking wood (or stone/tile) with a photographic layer and protective wear layer. Budget-friendly and DIY-friendly.

best for:

Budget-conscious homeowners, DIYers, living rooms, bedrooms, playrooms.  Moderate traffic areas.

Key benefits:

  • Most affordable hard flooring

  • Easy DIY install

  • Wide style variety

main Drawbacks:

  • Less realistic look/feel than real wood

  • Typically not water-resistant (limited waterproof versions)

  • Cannot be refinished

material cost:

$1 - $5 per sq ft

installation cost:

get a free quote

Luxury vinyl plank

Close up of a rustic wood grained LVP. Full Size for desktop

What is luxury vinyl plank?

Vinyl flooring mimicking hardwood planks. Multi-layer construction with durable wear layer, decorative wood-look print, and a vinyl core. Often waterproof.

best for:

Kitchens, bathrooms, basements, laundry rooms, high-traffic areas or really anywhere in the house! Homes with kids/pets. Anyone wanting a waterproof and durable wood-look.

Key benefits:

  • Water resistant/Waterproof options

  • Highly durable

  • Realistic wood look

  • DIY-friendly

main Drawbacks:

  • Difficult to repair

  • Can be dented (Some versions are more dent resistant)

  • Mid-range price can approach lower-end of engineered wood

material cost:

$3 - $8+ per sq ft

installation cost:

get a free quote

Luxury vinyl tile

Dark colored LVT flooring installed in modern kitchen. Full sized for desktop

What is luxury vinyl tile?

Vinyl flooring mimicking ceramic tile, porcelain, or stone. Similar construction to LVP. Often waterproof.

best for:

Kitchens, bathrooms, entryways, basements, laundry rooms. Homeowners wanting tile look but easier install and warmer feel underfoot.

Key benefits:

  • Much more affordable than traditional tile

  • Water resistant/Waterproof options

  • Tile look with vinyl comfort and warmth

  • Much easier install than tile

main Drawbacks:

  • Difficult to repair

  • Can be dented (Some versions are more dent resistant)

  • Mid-range price can approach lower-end of engineered wood

material cost:

$3 - $8+ per sq ft

installation cost:

get a free quote

sheet vinyl

Sheet vinyl installed in a modern apartment kitchen. Full sized for desktop

What is sheet vinyl?

Continuous, flexible vinyl flooring in large rolls. Most budget-friendly vinyl option, highly water-resistant.

best for:

Kitchens, bathrooms, entryways, basements, laundry rooms. Homeowners wanting tile, wood, squares etc. look but with an easier install and warm feel underfoot.

Key benefits:

  • Most affordable flooring

  • Excellent water resistance

  • Many style options available

main Drawbacks:

  • Least realistic look

  • Lower durability (thinner wear layers)

  • Damage is very difficult to repair without replacing the whole sheet

material cost:

$0.50 - $3 per sq ft

installation cost:

get a free quote